1929 - Margaret Dionne 1934 - Bernice Dittman 1941 - Dotty Duperrault 1949 - Phyllis Kessler Miss Wisconsin 1949 1950 - Joanna Washburn 1951 - Marlene Watermolen 1954 - Barbara Long 1967 - Terry Ann Meeuwsen Miss Wisconsin 1972 Miss America 1973 1968 - Nancy Gajafsky 1969 - Janice Gonnering 1970 - Sue Basche 1971 - Carol Ann Schmitt Miss Wisconsin 1974 1972 - Karen McDiarmid 1973 - Maryjo Steffel 1974 - Victoria Robbins 1974 - Michelle Akerboom Finished Victoria Robbin's reign 1989 - Angela Wright 1990 - Jennifer Campbell 1991 - Jill Huguet 1992 - Darlene Swille 1994 - Laura Voss Miss Wisconsin 1994 1994 - Michele Lu Maye Finished Laura Voss' reign 1995 - Shelly Lahti 1996 - Paula Van Drisse 1997 - Jill Persick 1998 - Tracy Lee Calkins - Delforge 1999 - Kelly Marie Kujava 2000 - Lisa Arndt 2001 - Tina Sauerhammer Miss Wisconsin 2003 Second Runner Up to Miss America 2003
2012 - Lauren McLester - Davis 2013 - Erin Schuessler Outstanding Teen Spirit Award 2014 - Paige Kassner Second Runner-Up 2015 - Bailey Hanson Outstanding Teen Spirit Award 2018 - Anika Mazier Third Runner-Up
